Kerplookee Fantasy Golf – Statistics, Streaks, or Just Flip a Coin?
If you know me, you’d know that I’ve never really been on the Tiger Woods fan bus. I have always respected and admired his talent on the golf course, but I’ve found myself drawn to other players that I like to root for. I’ve decided that my lack of Tiger enthusiasm was due in part for my need to root for the underdog and the idea that Tiger seemed to have enough fans already.
It wasn’t that long ago that when Tiger was in the field he was the odds on favorite to win every time…and his record proves that there was a reason to pick him – he won, a lot. Back in 2008, I had a bet with a friend on the WGC match play and he gave me one choice – Tiger or the field. One guy or 63 guys – and believe it or not, I took Tiger, and won!
In the past few weeks I’ve really come to appreciate more the success Tiger achieved during his whirlwind period of dominance as I have found it harder and harder to find players to have confidence in week after week.
Since the Tiger era has faded, no one has really stepped up to the plate to secure that “go to guy” status when looking to pick guys for my fantasy team (sidebar: the only reason Tiger does is due to his low salary – if he were in the $3.5-$4.5 million range, I’m not sure he’d be a lock anymore).
Even though Kerplookee didn’t use the WGC Match Play Championship, the results are telling as we move into a pre-Masters swing and we need to decide on which players will fit into those salary caps. Granted, a match play format is different than a 4-day stroke play event, but maybe it shows even more what clutch golf is all about. Seeing Luke Donald lose in the first round on Wednesday was like seeing Stricker lose last year in the first round. How does that happen?
If you believe the commentators and media folks, McIlory only made it as far as he did because the other guy was stinking it up worse than he was rather than it being Rory playing great. While 2 of the 4 brackets still had the #1 seed in the quarters, the other 2 had the 9th seed vs. the 10th seed and the 4th seed vs. the 6th seed playing for a spot in the semi’s. The number #1 seeds ended up playing each other in the semi’s but it was Hunter Mahan, a 6th seed, that won, and Mark Wilson, a 10th seed, that beat #1 seed Westwood in the 3rd place match. The WGC wasn’t exactly a vote of confidence for the best players in the world as we come into a few more events that will include many of these A-listers.
Kerplookee players did have to put their thinking caps on for the Mayakoba Classic this week. As a “lesser field” event there were no worries about salary caps so the decision is almost one of best of the field or the chance that a rookie or young gun might get hot. For one of my fantasy teams, I just took the top 10 valued players in the field. Now I know it might not make sense to consider last year’s results for this year’s event, but I figured what the heck. Here’s what I found out – 3 of the 10 missed the cut – and after waivering in Chris Stroud, I ended up making about $300K less than the 200th place finisher last week. Not so good.
I read a couple of comments in the forums that maybe it’s just as smart to throw darts at names since research and stats haven’t really paid off this year. I’d wonder if people could really do that versus going with their gut, or in my case, my heart. Maybe the solution is a little of everything.
It seems to me that just when we think we’ve found “the next Tiger”, it doesn’t take long for that player to give us reason to doubt it. I believe the bar has lowered and that gives more guys the chance to claw their way to the top…the question is, for how long? And as fantasy golfers, we now have to wonder if we need to focus on the guys on the way up or if the guys on top can continue to stay there. I’m hoping I can start finding that right combination soon!
by Cathy Erickson teetogreen.com